• About
  • Join the Co-op / Donate
  • Contact
Saturday, June 14, 2025
Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
The Brief
NB MEDIA CO-OP
Share a story
  • Articles en français
  • New Brunswick
  • Canada
  • World
  • Environment
  • Indigenous
  • Labour
  • Gender
  • Politics
  • Culture
  • Videos
  • NB debrief
  • Articles en français
  • New Brunswick
  • Canada
  • World
  • Environment
  • Indigenous
  • Labour
  • Gender
  • Politics
  • Culture
  • Videos
  • NB debrief
No Result
View All Result
NB MEDIA CO-OP
No Result
View All Result
Home *Opinion*

Vaughn Barnett sentence a travesty of justice

by NB Media Co-op Editorial Board
March 2, 2020
Reading Time: 4min read
Vaughn Barnett sentence a travesty of justice

Vaughn Barnett (photo supplied) and the Fredericton Courthouse.

In 2007, the last time Vaughn Barnett was sentenced to jail, they took him away in leg shackles for the same reason they did again last week. He tried to do what the justice system appears to make impossible in New Brunswick: to both follow the law and also help poor people who cannot afford a lawyer, do not qualify for legal aid and have nowhere else to turn.

On Feb. 27, Barnett, a Fredericton anti-poverty activist, was sentenced by New Brunswick Court of Queen’s Bench Chief Justice Tracey DeWare to 100 days in jail for contempt, for practicing law without a licence. It was a decision that pitted the Law Society of New Brunswick (LSNB) against Barnett.

Barnett obtained a law degree from the University of Western Ontario in 1994 but never became licenced.

All Barnett did, in his own description, was try to use the law in his activism to help a couple of people close to him who could not afford lawyers to challenge the government for unfair treatment. Barnett charged no money and is on social assistance himself.

Chief Justice DeWare noted that Barnett did not cause any physical harm to anyone, but considered his actions still harmful, saying his, “ability to do harm through the unlicensed practice of law is real, and, regretfully, unrelenting.”

“Unrelenting” refers to Barnett’s history. Since 2000, he has been under court orders to not to give legal advice, prepare legal documents or negotiate legal settlements, among other restrictions. Barnett has continued to restrict his activities to follow the court orders but did not want to abandon the urgent cause of trying to offer what help he was permitted. (Information about Barnett’s other restrictions and more background details are in a previous NB Media Co-op article about the case.)

The Law Society Act of New Brunswick prohibits unlicensed individuals or organizations from providing legal services, even if the assistance is free. The Act ensures that in New Brunswick, low income people will have difficulty obtaining any form of legal assistance where legal aid and pro bono assistance is not available.

In 2007, the now-defunct New Brunswick Access to Justice Coalition was formed in the wake of Barnett’s last contempt trial. The Coalition contacted the Canadian Civil Liberties Association (CCLA) in 2011 to raise an alarm about the terrible situation for access to justice in New Brunswick.

In response to Barnett’s ongoing plight and the access to justice issues that his story raised, the CCLA wrote to the Law Society of New Brunswick and then Minister of Justice and Community Affairs. They wrote:

… a large group of individuals in society are prohibited from providing help to others in matters relating to legal obligations and/or rights. For instance, in contrast to laws in many other Canadian provinces, the Act (Law Society Act of New Brunswick) appears to exclude people – including family, friends and neighbours – and community organizations from providing any legal support or advocacy assistance even without expectation or requirement of fee or reward.
(…)
The CCLA therefore strongly urges the New Brunswick Government and the Law Society of New Brunswick to amend the Law Society Act …

The government did not make the requested changes, and Vaughn now sits in jail, pending a possible appeal.

Regardless of what the Law Society Act says, Chief Justice DeWare’s decision begs the question of what the rule of law means for low income people in New Brunswick.

The rule of law requires that the legal system is accessible to all because the law applies to all. That is how it is supposed to be, which has very deep historical roots, clause 40 of the 800-year-old Magna Carta, a foundational document of our entire legal system, which states, “to no one will we sell, to no one will we refuse or delay, right or justice.”

Former Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC), Beverly McLachlin, once told a University of Toronto Law conference audience that access to justice, “is a fundamental right, not an accessory.” In 1988, her predecessor, Chief Justice Brian Dickson said, that access to justice is, “one of the most pressing and significant issues confronting the legal system today.” The refrain keeps going back through history. It’s an 800-year-old echo, but it cannot be heard in a New Brunswick courtroom.

The length of the sentence is another issue that should concern those who care about access to justice. A 100-day sentence is the kind of jail time given for assault causing bodily harm, breaking and entering a person’s home or other serious offences that cause physical harm and fear. Yet, as Chief Justice DeWare noted, there is no proof that Vaughn actually did any harm to anyone. To the contrary, Vaughn helped one individual avoid an unlawful arrest and helped another by raising the issue of unpaid trainees in New Brunswick.

We are told that the reason for the severe penalty on Vaughn is that society needs to be protected from Barnett. In contrast, we believe that the judgement and sentence is about protecting the legal profession from the prospect of a non-lawyer filling in gaps left by Law Society of NB members, because justice costs money.

Tags: anti-povertycourtjusticeLaw Society of New BrunswickVaughn Barnett
Send

Related Posts

New Brunswick

Johanne Petitpas, a pioneer of meaningful social change

August 6, 2021

On July 31st, 2021, an inspiring 62-year-old woman named Johanne Petitpas died suddenly from a massive heart attack. Grief was...

Decision to be made in anti-poverty activist’s contempt case
*Opinion*

On justice and the criminalization of advocacy: An update on Vaughn Barnett’s case

July 15, 2021

On February 27, 2020, Vaughn Barnett, a Fredericton anti-poverty activist, was sentenced by New Brunswick Court of Queen’s Bench Chief...

Decision to be made in anti-poverty activist’s contempt case
New Brunswick

Decision to be made in anti-poverty activist’s contempt case

January 30, 2020

New Brunswick Court of Queen’s Bench Chief Justice will give her decision in the case for contempt against Fredericton anti-poverty...

Common Front campaign targets myths, prejudices about people living in poverty
Economy

Common Front campaign targets myths, prejudices about people living in poverty

January 27, 2020

A campaign targeting the most common myths and prejudices about people living in poverty is being launched today (January 27,...

Load More

Recommended

Délai prolongé! COOP Média NB offre d’emploi : Journaliste vidéo autochtone

Toujours pas de justice cinq ans après le meurtre de Chantel Moore

4 days ago
Livestream: Local News Matters — Incubating local news in the Maritimes [video]

Livestream: Local News Matters — Incubating local news in the Maritimes [video]

11 hours ago
New Brunswick man among activists detained in Egypt ahead of March to Gaza

New Brunswick man among activists detained in Egypt ahead of March to Gaza

2 hours ago
The Millennium Scoop: an ongoing crisis for Indigenous families

The Millennium Scoop: an ongoing crisis for Indigenous families

4 days ago
NB Media Co-op

© 2019 NB Media Co-op. All rights reserved.

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Join the Co-op / Donate
  • Contact
  • Share a Story
  • Calendar
  • Archives

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Join the Co-op / Donate
  • Contact
  • Share a Story
  • COVID-19
  • Videos
  • New Brunswick
  • Canada
  • World
  • Arts & Culture
  • Environment
  • Indigenous
  • Labour
  • Politics
  • Rural

© 2019 NB Media Co-op. All rights reserved.

X
Did you like this article? Support the NB Media Co-op! Vous avez aimé cet article ? Soutenez la Coop Média NB !
Join/Donate