• About
  • Join/Donate
  • Contact
Saturday, January 23, 2021
No Result
View All Result
The Brief
NB MEDIA CO-OP
Share a story
  • New Brunswick
  • Canada
  • World
  • Environment
  • Indigenous
  • Labour
  • Gender
  • Politics
  • Arts & Culture
  • Videos
  • COVID-19
  • New Brunswick
  • Canada
  • World
  • Environment
  • Indigenous
  • Labour
  • Gender
  • Politics
  • Arts & Culture
  • Videos
  • COVID-19
No Result
View All Result
NB MEDIA CO-OP
No Result
View All Result
Home Gender

Respect peaceful protest and apologize to reproductive justice and transgender rights activists, write UNB Law Faculty to New Brunswick MLAs

Open Letter to the Members of the Legislative Assembly of New Brunswick

by Basil Alexander, Greg Bowley, Catherine Cotter, LA Henry, Anne Warner La Forest, Jason MacLean, Nicole O’Byrne, Kailey O’Neil, Maria Panezi, Karen Pearlston, Benjamin Perryman, Jane Thomson, Vokhid Urinov, Hilary Young
September 29, 2020
3 min read
Security evicts reproductive rights occupation outside New Brunswick Legislature

New Brunswick Legislative Assembly security, with Fredericton Police accompanying, attempt to disperse the encampment of protesters outside the Legislature, Friday, Sept. 25, 7:55pm. Photo from David Coon's Facebook page.

We, the undersigned members of the University of New Brunswick Faculty of Law, write to express in the strongest possible terms our disagreement and disappointment with the illegal and anti-democratic actions taken by the Legislative Assembly’s Speaker and Sergeant-at-Arms on the evening of Friday 25 September 2020.

That evening, a group of concerned people began a peaceful and lawful overnight protest on the grounds of the Legislature. Their protest was in response to the provincial government’s refusal to repeal a provision of the New Brunswick Medical Services Payment Act – regulation 84-20, Schedule 2a. 1 – that prohibits the funding of abortions outside hospitals.

The lawfulness of the regulation, which will effectively force the closure of Clinic 554 in Fredericton, is in serious question because it poses probable violations of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and the Canada Health Act.

Acting on no apparent legal authority, the Sergeant-at-Arms directed security officers to disrupt and disband Friday evening’s peaceful protest. Security officers presented members of the protest with a notice dated the same day purporting to preclude “camping” on the Legislature’s grounds. The notice stated that the Legislative Assembly has a responsibility to provide a safe and secure environment for all Members of the Legislative Assembly, staff, and visitors to the Legislative Precinct. The notice further stated that the Sergeant-at-Arms was acting under the Speaker’s authority.

The notice given to members of the protest, which began after the close of the Legislative Assembly’s normal hours of business, failed to cite any legislative provision or regulation authorizing the Speaker’s directive.

We recognize that the Speaker bears an important responsibility to maintain the safety and integrity of the Legislative Assembly, and to meet that responsibility, the Speaker must exercise a certain degree of discretion.

But as New Brunswick’s own Justice Ivan Rand explained in the Supreme Court of Canada’s canonical decision in Roncarelli v. Duplessis, “there is no such thing as absolute and untrammelled ‘discretion’, that is that action can be taken on any ground or for any reason that can be suggested to the mind of the administrator.” Discretion, Justice Rand continued, “necessarily implies good faith in discharging public duty.”

The unauthorized actions of the Speaker, the Sergeant-at-Arms, and the Legislative Assembly’s security officers in disrupting a peaceful protest mounted in support of reproductive rights and New Brunswick’s only trans-inclusive medical clinic fall well wide of this mark.

Indeed, their actions violate some of the most basic principles of the rule of law, such as that rules should apply to future, not past, events, and that rules should be transparent and understandable. Retroactive and unclear rules may be arbitrary and deny people any way of knowing what conduct is unlawful before they engage in it.

The retroactive rule used to break up Friday evening’s peaceful protest is an example of the Province’s repeated failure to respect the rule of law and democratic accountability when it comes to funding abortions performed outside hospitals.

Premier Higgs insists that the Province has received a legal opinion stating that the government’s inaction in respect of regulation 84-20, Schedule 2a. 1 is lawful. Having disclosed that much but no more, we call on Premier Higgs to make the Province’s legal opinion public so New Brunswickers can judge for themselves and hold the government accountable.

As Justice Rand further explained in Roncarelli v. Duplessis, “there is always a perspective within which a statute is intended to operate; and any clear departure from its lines or objects is just as objectionable as fraud or corruption.”

As the Legislative Assembly returns to work this week, we urge its honourable Members to commit to upholding the highest standards of the rule of law and democracy in New Brunswick.

Specifically, we ask the Legislative Assembly to apologize to those who assembled on the Legislature’s grounds to lawfully and peacefully stand up for reproductive justice and transgender rights, and to invite the members of the Save Clinic 554 Campaign to make their case before you for the repeal of regulation 84-20, Schedule 2a. 1

We also call on Premier Higgs to fully and frankly state his government’s legal opinion and rationale for refusing to repeal this regressive regulation.

28 September 2020

Basil Alexander

Greg Bowley

Catherine Cotter

LA Henry

Anne Warner La Forest

Jason MacLean

Nicole O’Byrne

Kailey O’Neil

Maria Panezi

Karen Pearlston

Benjamin Perryman

Jane Thomson

Vokhid Urinov

Hilary Young

Tags: abortionabortion accessFrederictonhealth careLegislative Assemblyprotestreproductive rightstransgenderUNBUNB Faculty of LawUniversity of New Brunswick
ShareTweetSend

Related Posts

*Opinion*

Finally, New Brunswick is being sued for unlawful restrictions on abortion access

January 18, 2021

This commentary was originally published by Briarpatch. On January 7, the Canadian Civil Liberties Association filed a lawsuit against the...

Axed bus routes blamed on Higgs’ refusal to accept public transportation funds
Economy

Axed bus routes blamed on Higgs’ refusal to accept public transportation funds

January 14, 2021

Maritime Bus plans to cut routes in New Brunswick due to the province's refusal to grant subsidies to the struggling...

Rent hikes and stagnant incomes leave New Brunswickers without housing this COVID winter
*Opinion*

Rent hikes and stagnant incomes leave New Brunswickers without housing this COVID winter

January 12, 2021

Imagine the shock if we were to wake to an overnight 50 per cent increase in fuel prices, making it...

Opposition Day features a bold display of male power against abortion access in the New Brunswick Legislature
*Opinion*

Opposition Day features a bold display of male power against abortion access in the New Brunswick Legislature

December 18, 2020

On Thursday, Dec. 17, Liberal MLA Isabelle Thériault (Caraquet) introduced a motion urging the government to remove existing legislation that...

Load More

Recommended

“The fight is not over”: Penobsquis women

Penobsquis’s battle for compensation to resume in May

10 years ago

Report on anti-Semitism seeks only to protect Israel

10 years ago
fundthefuture123

From Fredericton to Halifax, our challenges are the same

10 years ago

Egyptian authorities continue to detain Canadian filmmaker and emergency physician

7 years ago
NB Media Co-op

© 2019 NB Media Co-op. All rights reserved.

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Join/Donate
  • Contact
  • Share a Story
  • Calendar
  • Archives

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Join/Donate
  • Contact
  • Share a Story
  • COVID-19
  • Videos
  • New Brunswick
  • Canada
  • World
  • Arts & Culture
  • Environment
  • Indigenous
  • Labour
  • Politics
  • Rural

© 2019 NB Media Co-op. All rights reserved.

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In