• About
  • Join/Donate
  • Contact
Friday, March 24, 2023
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
The Brief
NB MEDIA CO-OP
Share a story
  • Articles en français
  • New Brunswick
  • Canada
  • World
  • Environment
  • Indigenous
  • Labour
  • Gender
  • Politics
  • Culture
  • Videos
  • NB debrief
  • Articles en français
  • New Brunswick
  • Canada
  • World
  • Environment
  • Indigenous
  • Labour
  • Gender
  • Politics
  • Culture
  • Videos
  • NB debrief
No Result
View All Result
NB MEDIA CO-OP
No Result
View All Result
Home Housing

FIRST PERSON: Bureaucratic violence and the Residential Tenancies Tribunal

A renter describes his ordeal navigating the tribunal, and argues new legislative changes will only favour landlords.

by Harrison Dressler
December 23, 2022
Reading Time: 5min read
Make rent cap permanent, ACORN NB tells province [video]

Nicola Taylor, chair of Acorn NB, speaks during a rally for rent control in Fredericton on September 17, 2022. Photo: Aditya Rao

Jill Green is a Conservative MLA and the current Minister of Service New Brunswick. In late November, Green introduced a bill that, if passed, would allow tenants to contest rent increases that exceed the Consumer Price Index on a case-by-case basis, by contacting the Residential Tenancies Tribunal.

The Conservative government’s solution to the province’s housing crisis is akin to placing a Band-Aid on a bullet wound. It requires, in Green’s words, “everybody to be working together.”

“We need the landlords to step up,” Green told reporters. “And we need the tenants to talk to us and tell us when they have a rent increase that they think is inappropriate.”

However, according to the CBC, 369 tenants submitted rent reviews to Service New Brunswick in 2022. Of these 369 applications, only 53 led to the denial of rent increases (another 31 were still under review). What gives?

The problems with the Conservative government’s solution are twofold. First, it puts tenants on the defensive, forcing ordinary people to defend themselves against their landlord’s poor behaviour. Second, it assumes that landlords and tenants share equal amounts of wealth, time, experience, and energy to deal with the Residential Tenancies Tribunal’s bureaucratic process.

Jill Green became Minister of Service New Brunswick and Housing in October. ACORN NB, a tenants organization, rallied for a permanent rent cap and tenant protections at her constituency office on the north side of Fredericton on November 1, 2022. Photo from ACORN NB.

In late September, my old roommate forwarded me a claim against our damage deposit filed by our previous landlord.

The document alleged that we had caused over $1,800 in damages. Immediately, I took to the internet to draft a response, attaching a handful of photos and emails as evidence.

The Residential Tenancies Tribunal assured me that I would soon receive a response by email.

In late October, I received a second claim in the mail.

This time, my landlord had doubled down, upping the cost of damages and adding wholly new damages to boot. The claim now clocked in at over $2,200.

Confused, I patiently waited to hear back from the Residential Tenancies Tribunal. The email, however, never arrived.

It had been lost in the shuffle, and by the time my old roommate had forwarded me his copy of the email, it was nearly too late. At this point, my landlord had added new pieces of evidence to his claim: email chains, statements from new tenants, and sales receipts.

Much of this evidence contradicted his initial claim filed months prior. At this point, I had little more than a weekend—four days in total—to submit evidence to counter my landlord’s numerous (and inconsistent) claims.

What’s more, my hearing was scheduled little more than one week in advance.

As a graduate student, I temporarily put my studies on hold and took to crafting a defence. I wrote three full sentences before my laptop shut off and refused to turn back on. It had died. Murphy’s Law? My hearing was in three days.

Jill Green, Minister of Service New Brunswick, defends Bill 25, An Act Respecting Residential Tenancies, at a legislative committee hearing on Friday, December 9, 2022. Screenshot: legnb.ca

I went to the library and pored over old photos. I called friends, rifled through text messages, and contacted my ex-neighbours. I panicked, and I fretted. Anxious, I re-read tense email chains and analyzed heated exchanges.

I soon realized that I was attempting to craft a legal defence using a system of rules and regulations that I was wholly unequipped to understand. What’s more, my busy weekly schedule did not permit careful contemplation.

The Residential Tenancies Act, first assented to in 1975, is more than 20,000 words long. The document is mired in legal jargon and contains thirty unique sections, many of which have their own subsections and exceptions. To date, the tribunal does not offer legal aid to tenants, and for many New Brunswickers, myself included, the document remains an enigma.

My hearing was an unmitigated failure.

The tribunal lost my evidence, and for several minutes, I was placed on the defensive. I panicked. Once my evidence turned up, I attempted to disassemble my landlord’s claims. But the officer in charge of my case was confused. I was effectively attempting to argue against three different and contradictory versions of reality.

As my hearing ended, the officer in charge of my case urged me to settle. This way, my landlord could not pursue legal action.

I lost the entirety of the damage deposit.

In theory, New Brunswick’s Residential Tenancies Tribunal is a neutral authority that resolves financial disputes between landlords and tenants through a process of mediation.

However, in practice, it’s anything but.

Fredericton-based immigration lawyer Jael Duarte says that the New Brunswick government needs to prioritize the vaccination of temporary foreign workers. Photo submitted.

According to Jael Duarte, the Tenants Advocate for New Brunswick, to the untrained eye, the Residential Tenancies Tribunal “seems like a neutral party.”

However, Duarte remains unconvinced. “They are not even a tribunal,” she explained over the phone. “It’s just a name.”

“A tribunal normally has a court, clear regulations and procedures, and a right to appeal,” she explained.

What about the province’s legal system?

“If you disagree with the decision of the tribunal, you can go to court,” Duarte told me.

“But, there are very few [legal] precedents in New Brunswick, and the few precedents have been decided in favour of the landlord.”

“The judge can only decide based on what [evidence] the lawyers have shown to the judge,” she explained. “So, obviously, the landlord has more ability to show [evidence] to the judge.”

In practice, ostensibly neutral bureaucracies like the Residential Tenancies Tribunal are never truly neutral spaces.

Wealth begets power, and power begets evidence.

In one corner, landlords sit with ample time, deep pockets, abundant resources, and serious financial incentives. In the other corner, tenants sit unprotected and unadvised. They often work long hours, have limited resources, and lack experience dealing with the law.

Bureaucracies, the Residential Tenancies Tribunal included, cover up society’s fundamental inequalities, and in this sense, they are violent. By maintaining systems of apparent order, bureaucrats can perform violent acts with the press of a button—rubber stamping evictions, siphoning damage deposits, and facilitating massive rent increases, for example.

Oh, you want to evict a single mother of three? By all means—there is a form for that, a timeline, and a process.

On February 22, 2022 Fredericton tenants at 91 Main Street held an action against their new landlord after a number of them were served eviction notices. Photo from ACORN NB.

Bureaucracies function by segmenting violent acts into their most manageable portions, allowing for the forceful eviction of sick, elderly, and struggling tenants to seem necessary, fair, and even moral.

How can we expect workers, students, minorities, single parents, disabled people, the sick, the elderly, and the poor to face off against a more powerful class of landlords, many of whom are wealthy financiers?

The Residential Tenancies Tribunal forces ordinary New Brunswickers with no prior experience to become independent, untrained, and unpaid lawyers. In practice, then, the province’s fledgling legal system relies on the involuntary labour of tenants to work.

In total, I spent more than twenty hours contesting my landlord’s claim. According to the Economic Research Institute, lawyers in Canada make an average of $77 per hour. In my case, this would have amounted to over $1,500—a hefty sum.

Who should I make the bill out to—the Conservative Party, the Residential Tenancies Tribunal, or my landlord? I also take cash.

I say flip the script. Flip the violent, tedious, and mentally draining bureaucratic process against the province’s landlords.

The logical (albeit partial) solution is simple: give New Brunswickers access to legal aid, no strings attached. Other solutions include introducing a permanent rent cap and enacting a human rights-based housing framework.

Legal frameworks that do not put the rights of tenants first uphold the power of landlords — full stop.

Premier Higgs, whose side are you on?

Harrison Dressler is a master’s student in history at Queen’s University. He writes about Canadian history, labour, politics, and the environment.

Tags: Blaine HiggsHarrison DresslerhousingJill GreenResidential Tenancies Tribunal
ShareTweetSend

Related Posts

‘Disrespectful’ speech shows Higgs doesn’t understand health crisis, says NB Health Coalition co-chair [video]
Health

‘Disrespectful’ speech shows Higgs doesn’t understand health crisis, says NB Health Coalition co-chair [video]

February 27, 2023

Premier Blaine Higgs delivered his State of the Province speech earlier this month, celebrating what he described as a booming...

COMMENTAIRE: Les déclarations du premier ministre ne sont pas logiques
Articles en français

COMMENTAIRE: Les déclarations du premier ministre ne sont pas logiques

February 27, 2023

Deux reportages récents concernant les soins de santé au Nouveau-Brunswick sont des plus préoccupants pour notre système public. Ces reportages...

Emergency services in Sackville area in decline
Health

COMMENTARY: Premier’s statements on health care make no sense, says head of New Brunswick Union

February 27, 2023

Two recent articles involving health care in New Brunswick are cause for concern for our public system. The articles demonstrate...

migrantworkersrex
Media

Call for Submissions: ‘Housing Justice is Migrant Justice.’ Seeking stories about the housing of migrants in New Brunswick

February 14, 2023

The Madhu Verma Migrant Justice Centre in partnership with the NB Media Co-op is looking to publish articles on the...

Load More

Recommended

In this battle with CUPE, it’s Higgs’ government that has the credibility problem

STATEMENT: Medavie still fails to recognize Truth and Reconciliation Day, says CUPE

4 days ago
COMMENTARY: New Brunswick needs to protect people in public housing from radon

COMMENTARY: New Brunswick needs to protect people in public housing from radon

6 days ago
DÉCLARATION : Medavie ne reconnaît toujours pas la Journée de la vérité et de la réconciliation

DÉCLARATION : Medavie ne reconnaît toujours pas la Journée de la vérité et de la réconciliation

4 days ago
Mi’gmaq title initiative in New Brunswick part of larger Land Back movement

Mi’gmaq title initiative in New Brunswick part of larger Land Back movement

4 hours ago
NB Media Co-op

© 2019 NB Media Co-op. All rights reserved.

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Join/Donate
  • Contact
  • Share a Story
  • Calendar
  • Archives

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Join/Donate
  • Contact
  • Share a Story
  • COVID-19
  • Videos
  • New Brunswick
  • Canada
  • World
  • Arts & Culture
  • Environment
  • Indigenous
  • Labour
  • Politics
  • Rural

© 2019 NB Media Co-op. All rights reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In