• About
  • Join the Co-op / Donate
  • Contact
Tuesday, June 17, 2025
Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
The Brief
NB MEDIA CO-OP
Share a story
  • Articles en français
  • New Brunswick
  • Canada
  • World
  • Environment
  • Indigenous
  • Labour
  • Gender
  • Politics
  • Culture
  • Videos
  • NB debrief
  • Articles en français
  • New Brunswick
  • Canada
  • World
  • Environment
  • Indigenous
  • Labour
  • Gender
  • Politics
  • Culture
  • Videos
  • NB debrief
No Result
View All Result
NB MEDIA CO-OP
No Result
View All Result
Home *Opinion*

Want to do something about systemic racism in policing in New Brunswick? We can start by banning the racist practice of carding

by Aditya Rao
June 26, 2020
Reading Time: 4min read
Want to do something about systemic racism in policing in New Brunswick? We can start by banning the racist practice of carding

Hundreds of people attended a Black Lives Matter rally in Fredericton on June 2, 2020. Photo by Sarah Kierstead.

Police chiefs, premiers and mayors across the country are on the hot seat right now being asked to defend police budgets and acknowledge that systemic racism in policing exists.

Let’s get one thing out of the way: There is no serious debate to be had about whether there is systemic racism in policing.

There is, and we know there is.

But asking police chiefs whether they believe systemic racism exists is the wrong question. We should be asking them what they plan to do about it.

There is something we can do immediately to eliminate one policing practice that clearly perpetuates systemic racism. Ban carding – the practice of stopping individuals and checking identification without grounds to detain or arrest the person.

This issue was raised briefly in New Brunswick when Public Safety Minister Carl Urquhart proposed new amendments to the Emergency Powers Act earlier this month that would have given broad carding powers to the police during emergencies. It would have gone further than that, giving police immunity from lawsuits for harm resulting from their conduct during an emergency, unless the harm meets the high standard of gross negligence.

Within just days of the announcement, the government withdrew the amendments facing criticism that changing emergency powers legislation during an emergency was bad form. Nicole O’Byrne, law professor at the University of New Brunswick, called it “a dramatic overreach by the executive to infringe or override the powers of the legislative assembly.”

People, especially people of colour, had good reason to be concerned about the practice.

Wherever carding is used, people of colour are stopped for street checks at disproportionately higher rates than white people.

In 2019, Nova Scotia instituted a moratorium on street checks because of evidence that Black people were street checked at a rate six times higher than white people in Halifax. Ontario has established strict rules governing when a police officer can ask an individual for identification, recognizing that street checks have disproportionately targeted Black and Indigenous communities. In 2018, Ontario Court of Appeal Judge Michael Tulloch called for the practice to be entirely abolished.

Despite what police chiefs and premiers believe, the fact that there is racism in policing across Canada has been established from data gathered about carding in various jurisdictions.

Still, police across New Brunswick use the practice.

Despite its widespread use, there is almost no data on police interactions with the public in New Brunswick that is broken down by race and ethnicity. But lack of data does not mean there is no racism in policing in New Brunswick.

In 2006, Asaf Rashid, a brown man, was arrested at a peaceful protest for refugee rights and then interrogated. Even though he was arrested alongside other white protesters, the police apparently singled only Rashid out for questions relating to his immigration status, and that of his family. A complaint was lodged, but no police officers faced any consequences for their behaviour.

In 2015, a Globe and Mail investigation found that Fredericton Police would not disclose even basic information such as the total number of street checks conducted, whether individuals stopped are informed of their rights, or even whether Fredericton police follow a specific procedure when conducting street checks.

A Daily Gleaner investigation in January of this year, however, uncovered some of those numbers. It confirmed that street checks are widely used by police in New Brunswick and that, except in Fredericton, police in New Brunswick do not collect race-related data while conducting street checks.

An analysis of the data from Fredericton showed that Indigenous people were found to have been stopped at a rate that is more than double that of the proportion they make up in the population at large.

People in Toronto rallying for justice for Chantel Moore. Photo by Kayla Fast.

Indigenous people in New Brunswick are all too familiar with racism in policing. Just this month, Chantel Moore, a 26-year-old Indigenous woman, was killed by Edmundston police after they were called to perform a wellness check on her. Her death is part of a pattern of violence against Indigenous women and girls across the country.

Just over a week later, an RCMP officer shot and killed Rodney Levi, a 48-year-old Indigenous man of Metepenagiag First Nation near Miramichi. Following these deaths, calls are mounting for New Brunswick to conduct a probe of anti-Indigenous bias in policing.

This bias is most regularly visible through carding.

Not only is carding a racist practice, it is also a practice without a shred of evidence to support police claims that it is effective in preventing crime or protecting the public. Carding simply allows police to infringe on individuals’ right to liberty and privacy, causing harm to communities of colour, thereby causing harm to the public.

We do not need more studies of carding to ban it in New Brunswick. Conducting more studies would mean using people of colour as guinea pigs in an unnecessary experiment that maintains police violence and discrimination against them.

As jurisdictions around the world question modern policing altogether, New Brunswick can take immediate action against systemic racism in policing by starting with a ban on carding.

Aditya Rao is a Fredericton lawyer and has been carded in two provinces. You can follow him on twitter at @aditrao.

Tags: Aditya Raocardingpoliceracismstreet checks
Send

Related Posts

Canada has a border wall called the Safe Third Country Agreement. Carney can tear it down
Immigration

Canada has a border wall called the Safe Third Country Agreement. Carney can tear it down

May 22, 2025

Canada has built a wall. It may not be Trump’s ugly border wall along the U.S.-Mexico border designed to keep...

‘The life of dust’: Black children in post-war Vietnam

‘The life of dust’: Black children in post-war Vietnam

April 16, 2025

Children of soldiers, left behind, are more than just collateral damage, according to scholar. On April 3, the University of...

Wolastoq Grand Chief says police racially profiled him in Ireland [video]
Indigenous

Wolastoq Grand Chief says police racially profiled him in Ireland [video]

March 25, 2025

An Indigenous Elder says police racially profiled and aggressively questioned him in Dublin, Ireland earlier this month. Wolastoq Grand Chief...

No timeline yet on pay equity bill promised during election campaign [video]
Economy

No timeline yet on pay equity bill promised during election campaign [video]

March 13, 2025

On International Women’s Day, a crowd marched through the streets of downtown Moncton. Their message: the time is now for...

Load More

Recommended

Local News Matters — Incubating local news in the Maritimes [video]

Local News Matters — Incubating local news in the Maritimes [video]

3 days ago
Délai prolongé! COOP Média NB offre d’emploi : Journaliste vidéo autochtone

Toujours pas de justice cinq ans après le meurtre de Chantel Moore

7 days ago
The Millennium Scoop: an ongoing crisis for Indigenous families

The Millennium Scoop: an ongoing crisis for Indigenous families

7 days ago
New Brunswicker deported from Egypt following crackdown on March to Gaza [video]

New Brunswicker deported from Egypt following crackdown on March to Gaza [video]

3 days ago
NB Media Co-op

© 2019 NB Media Co-op. All rights reserved.

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Join the Co-op / Donate
  • Contact
  • Share a Story
  • Calendar
  • Archives

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Join the Co-op / Donate
  • Contact
  • Share a Story
  • COVID-19
  • Videos
  • New Brunswick
  • Canada
  • World
  • Arts & Culture
  • Environment
  • Indigenous
  • Labour
  • Politics
  • Rural

© 2019 NB Media Co-op. All rights reserved.

X
Did you like this article? Support the NB Media Co-op! Vous avez aimé cet article ? Soutenez la Coop Média NB !
Join/Donate